Published Nov 19, 2026 · Updated Nov 19, 2026 · 13 min read
Gorgias Alternatives 2026: 6 Compared for Shopify and DTC Stores
Six Gorgias alternatives ranked on RTCI's score and filtered for Shopify and DTC support, with what each can do on a Shopify order, when staying on Gorgias is the better call, and a worked month at 1,800 tickets.

The Gorgias alternatives that score highest in RTCI's index and connect to a Shopify store are YourGPT (960, ~$0.13 per resolution, an estimate), Robylon (783, $0.29 to $0.64) and Help Scout (744, $0.50 to $0.75). Tidio Lyro (697) fits small chat-first stores, and Intercom's Fin (696, $0.99 per outcome) is the closest match on AI order actions. Gorgias AI itself has a benchmark rank of #2 of 20 and an RTCI score of 636 (Moderate): its AI acts on Shopify orders inside the helpdesk, but its realistic resolution rate of 27 to 37% is the lowest in the index.
A higher score does not settle the choice. Stay on Gorgias if your tickets are mostly Shopify order actions and several people answer them. Look elsewhere if your store is not on Shopify, if you need a monthly bill that does not climb with AI success, or if your AI volume will run well past the plan's allowance. This guide ranks six options on the same data, says what each documents for Shopify, and prices one month at 1,800 tickets.
Why stores look for Gorgias alternatives
The AI bill rises faster than the list rate suggests. The Gorgias pricing page, read on November 19, 2026, prices each plan with a prepaid AI allowance: Pro is $471 a month on annual billing, which is $300 for the helpdesk plus 190 automated interactions at $0.90. Above the allowance each interaction costs $1.50. At RTCI's realistic rate, the AI line works out to about $1.30 per resolution on Basic, Pro and Advanced. The Gorgias pricing guide shows the math for three store sizes.
Every AI resolution is also a ticket. The pricing FAQ says each AI Agent interaction also counts as a helpdesk ticket. Turning AI on does not shrink your ticket count, so it never moves you to a smaller plan.
The realistic resolution rate is low. Gorgias guarantees 50% automation in 50 days. RTCI discounts that as an unqualified figure (×0.75) and as automation rather than resolution (×0.85), which gives a realistic 27 to 37% (see the Gorgias AI review). At 1,800 conversations a month, that leaves about 1,226 for people.
The AI order actions are Shopify-only. The helpdesk connects to WooCommerce on every plan, BigCommerce from Basic and Magento from Pro, but RTCI's review cites Gorgias's docs (checked September 2, 2026) saying Order Management and autonomous order actions are Shopify-only. A WooCommerce or BigCommerce store pays for the AI allowance without the actions that make it useful.
Starter is narrow. The $40 Starter plan (monthly only, with AI Agent) has 3 user seats, 50 tickets, and no AI Agent Actions for cancellations or discounts.
Gorgias alternatives ranked on RTCI's data
The six alternatives are ranked by RTCI score, which combines the realistic resolution rate and the AI cost per resolution on one scale. They are filtered to platforms in RTCI's index that document a Shopify connection. Scores, rates and costs come from RTCI's index as of November 2026; the Shopify column is what each vendor's own page says, linked in the sections below. Gorgias is the baseline row.
| Rank | Platform | Type | RTCI score | Realistic resolution rate | AI cost per resolution | Pricing model | Shopify, as documented |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | YourGPT | AI agent platform | 960, Elite | 90% (RTCI test, Nov 2026) | ~$0.13 (est.) | Flat monthly plan with AI credits | Order lookup and tracking, add to cart |
| 2 | Robylon | AI agent with optional agent seats | 783, Elite | 59–69% | $0.29–$0.64 | Credits per conversation | Order lookup, refunds, returns, address edits; also WooCommerce and BigCommerce |
| 3 | Help Scout | Helpdesk replacement | 744, Strong | 54–64% | $0.50–$0.75 | Per resolution + seats | Agents refund, cancel and edit orders from the sidebar; AI use not documented |
| 4 | Tidio Lyro | Chat and AI agent for small stores | 697, Strong | 55–65% | $0.77–$1.18 | Per AI conversation | Lyro checks order status; cancel and refund are agent actions |
| 5 | Intercom Fin | Helpdesk replacement with AI | 696, Strong | 56–66% | $0.99 | Per outcome + seats | Order status, returns and refunds; Shopify only |
| 6 | Kustomer AI | CRM-centric helpdesk replacement | 590, Moderate | 37–47% | $1.60–$2.03 | Per engaged conversation + seats by quote | Shopify order search |
| Baseline | Gorgias AI | Incumbent | 636, Moderate | 27–37% | $0.90–$1.00 | Plan with prepaid AI allowance, $1.50 overage | Native order actions; Shopify only |
Two rows need the most checking. YourGPT's 90% comes from one RTCI test on a SaaS support workload, not on a store, and its ~$0.13 spreads the $349 Advanced plan over about 2,700 resolutions a month. Robylon's range comes from its published credit prices divided by RTCI's realistic rate. Kustomer scores below Gorgias; it is here because it is the other helpdesk built around DTC customer records.
Left out on purpose: HubSpot Service Hub (762) and Freshdesk Freddy (703) score well but are general helpdesks, and RTCI has not found documentation of their AI agents acting on Shopify orders; the Zendesk alternatives guide covers both. Ada CX (799, est.) is an enterprise contract and appears below as the one AI layer that documents a handoff into Gorgias. Zendesk AI (592) and Salesforce Agentforce (588) score below Gorgias, and Decagon, Sierra and Kore.ai are quote-only contact-centre purchases. Yuma and Richpanel are not in RTCI's index; the ecommerce platforms guide covers them.
Lowest AI cost: YourGPT and Robylon
1. YourGPT. A no-code AI agent platform on flat monthly plans: Essential $39, Professional $79 and Advanced $349 a month billed yearly, with included AI credits and no per-resolution fee. Extra credits cost $7 per 2M and extra team members $7 a month each. YourGPT's Shopify integration page says the store connects from the dashboard without code, and the agent can look up and track orders and add items to a shopper's cart and send them to checkout. The page does not mention refunds or cancellations.
It suits stores with enough volume to spread a flat fee thin, whose top tickets are order status and product questions. It is not for stores that need the AI to refund or cancel orders on its own, or whose procurement needs a published per-resolution price. RTCI has not tested YourGPT on a Shopify store, so run a credit-burn and resolution test on your own conversations, and check how human handoff and ticket history work before moving off Gorgias. See the YourGPT review.
2. Robylon. An omnichannel AI agent (chat, WhatsApp, email and voice) on credit plans: a free Starter tier, Pro from $22 a month and Business from $162 a month billed yearly, up to 10,000 credits for $270. Each chat, WhatsApp or email conversation uses about 7.5 credits, roughly $0.20 to $0.38, whether or not it resolves; extra credits are $25 per 1,000, and live-agent seats are $19, $49 or $89 a month. Robylon's integrations page lists Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce and Salesforce Commerce Cloud, and for Shopify says the agent can check orders, start returns and edit shipping details, with each action limited to what the store allows.
It is the strongest option here for stores that are not on Shopify, because Gorgias's and Fin's AI order actions are Shopify-only. It is not for teams that cannot plan around AI replies pausing when credits run out, and the voice credit rate is not published. See the Robylon review.
Helpdesk replacements with an AI agent
3. Help Scout. Standard $25, Plus $45 and Pro $75 per user a month, and the AI agent costs $0.75 per resolution, or less with prepaid resolutions. Help Scout's Shopify article, updated November 5, 2026, says agents can refund, cancel, edit or duplicate a customer's recent orders from the conversation sidebar. It does not say the AI agent can read or act on Shopify orders.
It suits email-first stores with a small team that want simple per-resolution billing. It is not for stores that want the AI, rather than an agent, to process refunds and cancellations, or for large teams: 15 people on Plus cost $675 a month in seats, against $300 for Gorgias Pro's helpdesk on annual billing. See the Help Scout AI review.
4. Tidio Lyro. The Lyro AI agent starts at $32.50 a month billed annually ($39 monthly) for 50 conversations and is billed per conversation it replies to; the largest self-serve quota is 1,000 conversations for $700 a month on monthly billing. Tidio's Shopify integration page says Lyro can check order statuses and answer delivery and returns questions; cancelling orders, offering refunds and changing addresses are listed as agent actions in the inbox.
It suits small chat-first stores that want a cheap AI layer on their chat widget. It is not for stores above 1,000 AI conversations a month, where Tidio moves to a quoted Premium plan. See the Tidio Lyro review.
5. Intercom Fin. Fin for Ecommerce costs $0.99 per outcome. Fin's Shopify page says it connects to Shopify's APIs to check order status and to handle order tracking, returns and refunds, and that the ecommerce role requires a Shopify integration: Shopify is the only supported ecommerce platform for it. On Intercom's own helpdesk, seats are Essential $29 ($19 for new customers), Advanced $85 and Expert $132.
It suits Shopify stores that want AI order actions with a higher realistic rate than Gorgias's: 56 to 66% against 27 to 37%. It is not for stores on other platforms, and an outcome is broader than a resolution, so sample billed outcomes to check your real unit cost. RTCI's Intercom Fin vs Gorgias AI comparison runs the two side by side, and the Intercom Fin review has the detail.
6. Kustomer AI. Concierge, the customer-facing AI, costs $0.75 per engaged conversation, billed whether or not it resolves, and seats are by quote. RTCI's review cites a Shopify Search Orders tool in Kustomer's fall 2025 product release notes. It suits larger DTC brands that want the customer record, not the ticket, at the centre of support. It is not for small stores or for buyers who need published seat prices, and at $1.60 to $2.03 per resolution it costs more than Gorgias. See the Kustomer AI review and Kustomer pricing guide.
Keep Gorgias, swap the AI?
Few AI vendors document a connection into Gorgias. Ada CX does: its Gorgias handoff guide says the connector creates a ticket in Gorgias and relays messages and attachments both ways. Handoff tickets appear as email-style tickets in Gorgias rather than live chats, and Gorgias's API rate limits can delay relays at peak. Ada is sold on annual enterprise contracts by quote (RTCI's ~$0.40 per resolution is a low-confidence estimate), so it fits large stores only. Fin's helpdesk integrations page names Salesforce, Zendesk, Freshdesk and HubSpot, not Gorgias.
If you do this, every conversation Ada hands to people still becomes a billable Gorgias ticket. You stop paying Gorgias for automated interactions only on conversations its own AI Agent never touches.
What one month costs at 1,800 tickets
Worked example: a Shopify store receives 1,800 conversations a month and five people answer what the AI does not resolve. Every conversation goes to the AI first. Prices are annual list prices as of November 2026. Each AI resolves at the midpoint of RTCI's realistic range, except YourGPT at its 90% test result. Gorgias runs on Pro with AI Agent ($471), as in the Gorgias pricing guide.
| Option | Plan or seats | AI resolutions (of 1,800) | AI cost | Monthly total | Left for people |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stay: Gorgias Pro | $471, incl. 190 AI interactions | 574 (31.9%) | $576 overage (384 × $1.50) | $1,047 | 1,226 |
| YourGPT Advanced | $349 flat | 1,620 (90%) | Included in plan | $349 | 180 |
| Robylon Business | $95 to $445 (5 seats at $19 to $89) | 1,148 (63.8%) | $357.50 ($270 for 10,000 credits + 3,500 extra at $25 per 1,000) | $452.50 to $802.50 | 652 |
| Help Scout Plus | $225 (5 × $45) | 1,055 (58.6%) | $791.25 (1,055 × $0.75) | $1,016.25 | 745 |
| Intercom Essential + Fin | $145 (5 × $29) | 1,094 outcomes (60.8%) | $1,083.06 (1,094 × $0.99) | $1,228.06 | 706 |
| Kustomer + Concierge | Seats by quote | 749 (41.6%) | $1,350 (1,800 × $0.75) | $1,350 plus seats | 1,051 |
Tidio Lyro is missing on purpose: its largest self-serve quota is 1,000 Lyro conversations a month, below the 1,800 here. Ada is missing because it publishes no price.
Four assumptions move the totals. YourGPT fits Advanced only if credit use stays within its 100M credits; at the review's ~25,000 credits per GPT-4o conversation, 1,800 conversations use about 45M, so Professional ($79, 30M credits) plus 8 extra packs ($56) for $135 might also cover it if that plan includes the features you need. YourGPT adds $7 a month for each team member beyond the plan's allowance. Robylon's range is the seat tier you pick. Help Scout's AI line falls with prepaid resolutions, and Fin's seat line falls to $95 at the $19 new-customer rate, making that row $1,178.06.
The cheapest bill is not always the cheapest month. Gorgias leaves 1,226 conversations for people, against 180 with YourGPT and 706 with Fin, and its AI line works out to $1.30 per resolution ($171 allowance + $576 overage ÷ 574). But the AI rates for the alternatives are index estimates, mostly not measured on stores, and only Gorgias, Fin and Robylon document AI refunds on Shopify. Price your own cost per human ticket before reading the totals as a ranking.

Stay with Gorgias if…
Most of your tickets are Shopify order actions. Gorgias's AI Agent reads live Shopify orders and can track, return, refund, cancel and edit addresses inside the helpdesk where your team already works. Among the alternatives, only Fin and Robylon document AI refunds on Shopify.
Many people answer tickets. Gorgias charges by tickets, not seats (500 seats from Basic up). Per-seat alternatives get more expensive with every hire; 15 Help Scout Plus users cost $675 a month before any AI.
Your AI volume stays near the allowance. If AI Agent handles one channel or a narrow set of intents, you pay the plan price and little or no $1.50 overage.
Your measured automated share is well above 37%. RTCI's range is an estimate. Take last quarter's automated interactions, subtract any that reached an agent within 72 hours, and divide by conversations. A higher rate means fewer tickets for people at a unit price that tops out at $1.50.
If you stay, size the allowance to your real automated volume. Each interaction moved from overage into the allowance saves $0.60 on annual billing; the Gorgias pricing guide has the other negotiation points.
The decision rule
Not on Shopify: shortlist Robylon, because Gorgias's AI order actions do not work for you. On Shopify and want AI that refunds and returns with a higher realistic rate: test Fin. Want a flat or capped AI bill: YourGPT or Robylon. A small chat-first store: Tidio Lyro. An email-first team of a few people: Help Scout. A larger DTC brand organized around customer records: Kustomer. Otherwise, a Shopify store with an order-heavy queue and a large team is usually best served by staying on Gorgias and fixing the allowance.
Before you switch, put your own conversations, seats and resolution rate into the cost per verified resolution calculator and compare monthly totals, not headline rates.
How RTCI calculates these numbers
- Realistic resolution rate. Each vendor’s published claim is discounted by one fixed rule for every vendor, with an extra discount when the figure measures deflection rather than resolution.
- Cost per resolution. Per-session and per-conversation prices are divided by that realistic rate, because failed attempts are billed too. Mandatory platform fees are spread over 2,000 to 4,000 resolutions a month.
- Prices. Every price links to the vendor’s own page as of the date shown. Costs marked ~ or est. are RTCI estimates for vendors that publish no per-unit price.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best alternative to Gorgias?
For a Shopify store that wants AI to act on orders, Intercom's Fin: $0.99 per outcome, a realistic 56 to 66% resolution rate, and documented Shopify order status, returns and refunds. For the lowest AI cost, YourGPT (~$0.13 per resolution, an RTCI estimate) and Robylon ($0.29 to $0.64). For a small chat-first store, Tidio Lyro. If most tickets are Shopify order actions and your team is large, staying on Gorgias is often the better call.
Is there a cheaper alternative to Gorgias?
On AI cost, yes. In RTCI's worked month at 1,800 tickets, Gorgias Pro with AI Agent costs $1,047 on annual billing. YourGPT Advanced ($349 flat) and Robylon ($452.50 to $802.50 with five agent seats) cost less and, at index rates, resolve more. Help Scout Plus with five users comes to $1,016.25. Gorgias does not charge per seat, so it gets relatively cheaper as the number of people answering tickets grows.
What is the best Gorgias alternative for WooCommerce or BigCommerce stores?
Robylon. Its integrations page lists Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce and Salesforce Commerce Cloud, with order lookups, refunds, returns and address edits scoped by the store. Gorgias's helpdesk connects to WooCommerce and BigCommerce, but RTCI's review cites Gorgias docs saying its autonomous order actions are Shopify-only. Fin's ecommerce role is also Shopify-only.
Can I keep Gorgias and use a different AI agent?
Ada CX documents a Gorgias handoff: Ada answers first and, on escalation, creates a Gorgias ticket and relays messages both ways. It is an enterprise contract by quote. Fin's helpdesk integrations page names Salesforce, Zendesk, Freshdesk and HubSpot, not Gorgias. Any ticket an AI layer hands to Gorgias still counts as a billable Gorgias ticket.
Is Gorgias better than Zendesk for a Shopify store?
On RTCI's index, Gorgias AI scores 636 (Moderate) against 592 for Zendesk AI (Moderate), and Gorgias's AI acts on Shopify orders inside the helpdesk. Zendesk relies on Shopify marketplace apps. RTCI's guide to Zendesk alternatives for ecommerce covers that comparison.
Why do people leave Gorgias?
The usual reasons in the pricing are the prepaid AI allowance, the $1.50 overage above it, and the rule that every automated interaction also counts as a helpdesk ticket. On outcomes, RTCI's realistic resolution rate for Gorgias AI is 27 to 37%, the lowest in its index. Stores not on Shopify also lose the AI order actions.
Change log
- Published.
Read next
Keep reading
Picked for this article: the pieces it cites and the ones that answer the next question buyers usually ask.

Most related
Gorgias Pricing 2026: Plans, AI Agent Fees and Cost per Resolution
Gorgias pricing as of November 19, 2026: what each plan costs with AI Agent switched on, the $1.50 AI overage, the ticket double count, and a worked monthly bill at 250, 1,800 and 5,000 tickets.

Intercom Fin vs Gorgias AI for Ecommerce
Intercom Fin vs Gorgias AI on RTCI numbers: realistic resolution rates, what each one bills, a worked cost comparison, an ecommerce scorecard and a two-week pilot plan.

Best AI Support Platforms for Ecommerce (2026)
Ecommerce shortlist: Gorgias, Yuma, Richpanel, Intercom Fin, Gladly, Decagon, and Zendesk AI compared on order actions, returns, subscriptions, Shopify depth and cost per verified resolution, with worked cost examples from published prices.

Zendesk Alternatives 2026: 8 Compared on AI Cost per Resolution
Eight Zendesk alternatives ranked on RTCI's score and AI cost per resolution as of November 2026, split into AI layers that run on Zendesk and full helpdesk replacements, with a worked month at 5,000 tickets.

Best Zendesk Alternatives for Ecommerce: 4 AI Support Options
Four AI support options for ecommerce teams replacing Zendesk, with RTCI index figures for each, the order and action checks to run in a demo, and how to compare cost per verified resolution.